The collapse of the West is first and foremost due to the failure of its economic system. Unfeathered capitalism is leading to liberalism's predictable self-canibalization.
Graziano Ceddia and Jacopo Bergamo join Pascal to explore the connections between capitalism, ecological destruction and Europe’s growing social unrest. Drawing on Marxian analysis, they discuss protests, inequality, imperialism and the limits of green investment. The conversation considers China’s development, competing forms of ownership and the resilience of capitalism. Ceddia and Bergamo argue for economic democracy and public provision of essential services, while Lottaz presses them on practical alternatives, monetary reform and the possibilities for social and ecological change.
Graziano and Jacopo's Links:
Homepage: www.iscrises.org
Their work in Monthly Review: https://monthlyreview.org/article-author/jacopo-nicola-bergamo/
Neutrality Studies Links:
Neutrality Studies Substack: https://pascallottaz.subst
Article
## A crisis of accumulation at the heart of social and ecological breakdown
What emerges from the conversation is a single, unsettling diagnosis: contemporary social unrest and ecological collapse are not coincidental aggregates of separate failures but symptoms of a deeper crisis in the mode of capital accumulation that structures modern life. The discussion insists that capitalism is not merely an economic mechanism among others but a social logic whose imperative—endless expansion of exchange value—systematically undermines the material foundations of human welfare and ecological stability. Protests on the streets of Europe, the spike in energy and food prices, and the accelerating loss of biodiversity are thus read not as isolated policy problems but as outcomes of a system whose reproductive needs increasingly collide with planetary boundaries and social reproduction.
This framing refuses the comforting fiction that greener labels, better regulations, or technocratic fine-tuning can restore equilibrium. Instead, what the exchange places at center stage is a structural tension: accumulation seeks profit and exchange-value growth, while nature and labor, the sources of all use-values, are being depleted or impoverished in the process. The conversation pushes readers to treat ecological crisis and social crisis as two sides of the same coin—both produced by the dynamics of accumulation—and to ask what political and institutional alternatives could interrupt that destructive loop.
## Europe’s unrest: more than a protest wave
The recent wave of demonstrations across Europe is portrayed in the discussion as more than episodic anger; it is an expression of living conditions fraying under the weight of rising costs, precarious housing, and austerity-prone public services. Rather than seeing these mobilizations as narrowly political or culturally driven, the conversation situates them squarely within the lived consequences of an economy where corporate profits and speculative returns have been prioritized over social provision. Logistics workers, farmers, and urban populations are joining in ways that cut across traditional party or union lines, signaling a disintermediation of political representation.
Notably, the conversation highlights how ecological stressors—heatwaves, crop losses, spikes in fuel prices—have amplified discontent and given the protests a material logic. When diesel prices undermine farmers’ livelihoods and extreme weather shrinks harvests, the abstract macros of GDP and markets convert rapidly into the concrete inability to feed families or keep homes. This makes the unrest difficult to contain with familiar policies: citizens demand security in the strongest sense—guarantees of health, housing, education, and protection from climate risks—rather than mere short-term financial relief. In this reading, Europe's street politics are a visible symptom of systemic decay and a potential opening for rethinking public provision.
## CRISES and the Marxian contribution to socio-ecological analysis
A recurring theme in the conversation is the explanatory power of Marxian analysis for integrating social and ecological crises. Rather than offering a nostalgic return to dogma, the approach is presented as a theoretical toolkit that clarifies how accumulation operates and why it produces both inequality and environmental degradation. Capital is reconstructed not as a static asset but as a dynamic process: self-valorizing value whose essential logic is circulation from money to commodities and back to greater money. This circulating imperative privileges exchange-value and reduces use-value—what goods actually do for people and ecosystems—to the status of a means.
The contribution of such an analysis is twofold. First, it exposes root causes: not merely corporate malpractice or weak regulations, but the structural constraint that profit-driven accumulation imposes on ecological limits and social reproduction. Second, it furnishes a normative and strategic horizon. If crises stem from accumulation, then reforms that leave that accumulation logic intact (call them greener branding or fiscal tinkering) will at best produce temporary relief and at worst legitimize new rounds of exploitation. The conversation thus argues for analytic clarity: understanding the system’s logic is a prerequisite for imagining transformational alternatives.
## Imperialism, geopolitical realignments, and the energy politics of accumulation
The exchange moves from theory to geopolitics by arguing that the current stage of capitalism—defined by intense imperial competition and the centrality of energy and armaments—exacerbates socio-ecological contradictions. Western capital, particularly the political-economic bloc anchored by the United States, is described as having doubled down on fossil fuel linkages and militarized accumulation. This reorientation makes a genuine transition to sustainability politically costly for incumbent powers, since energy security and military-industrial benefits are tied to hydrocarbons and arms production.
At the same time, the conversation draws attention to a crucial geopolitical twist: large parts of the Global South, led by major industrializing states, are deploying alternative pathways that combine state-led infrastructural investment with industrial policy. The result is a multipolar economic landscape where “centers” and “peripheries” of accumulation no longer map neatly onto old Cold War binaries. In practice, some actors in the Global South are pushing massive deployments of renewables and domestic industrial capacity—moves that both challenge the financialized accumulation model dominant in the global center and create new tensions over resource, market, and technology control. The point is not to romanticize any single state model but to note that the fracturing of global accumulation pathways is central to current ecological and social instability.
## The limits of green investment and the politics of “sustainability”
The conversation is sharply critical of the popular belief that green investment, carbon markets, or corporate sustainability pledges can solve the intertwined crises. Sustainability, as a term, has been hollowed out and repurposed as a vehicle for accumulation—greenwashing capital—rather than a serious constraint on profit-driven practices. Where capital is confronted with material barriers to expansion, it may redirect investment toward supposedly green sectors, but these moves are often designed to preserve value extraction rather than to reconfigure production toward social needs.
Two linked problems emerge. First, market-based green solutions tend to commodify nature further: offsetting, tradeable permissions, and assetization of ecological functions can transform ecosystems into speculative instruments. Second, in contexts where political elites depend on fossil rents and military-industrial complexes, green capital initiatives may be subordinated to strategic imperatives rather than ecological or social ones. The conversation insists that without changing the underlying social relations—who owns what, who decides priorities, and what metrics govern success—green finance will remain a partial, and potentially counterproductive, instrument.
## Toward economic democracy: public provision, monetary reform, and institutional alternatives
If the problem is structural, the responses must be too. The conversation advances a practical, if ambitious, agenda centered on economic democracy and public provision of essential services. Rather than treating welfare and public goods as concessions, the argument reframes health, housing, education, and energy as foundations of social reproduction that should be decommodified and guaranteed through democratic control. This implies an expanded role for public ownership, collective management, and participatory institutions that can prioritize use-value and ecologic
Transcript
Researchers Show: West Is Collapsing
FASTER Than Expected | G. Ceddia & J.
Bergamo
The collapse of the West is first and foremost due to the failure of its economic system. Unfeathered
capitalism is leading to liberalism's predictable self-canibalization. Graziano Ceddia and Jacopo
Bergamo join Pascal to explore the connections between capitalism, ecological destruction and
Europe’s growing social unrest. Drawing on Marxian analysis, they discuss protests, inequality,
imperialism and the limits of green investment. The conversation considers China’s development,
competing forms of ownership and the resilience of capitalism. Ceddia and Bergamo argue for
economic democracy and public provision of essential services, while Lottaz presses them on
practical alternatives, monetary reform and the possibilities for social and ecological change.
Graziano and Jacopo's Links: Their work in Monthly Review: https://monthlyreview.org/article-author
/jacopo-nicola-bergamo/ Neutrality Studies Links: Neutrality Studies Substack: https://pascallottaz.
substack.com Support Neutrality Studies: https://neutralitystudies.com/donate Neutrality Studies
shop: https://neutralitystudies.com/shop Time Stamps 00:00 Europe’s protests and social unrest 07:
56 Graziano on the roots of discontent 12:29 CRISES: connecting society and ecology 16:09
Capitalism, imperialism and the climate 27:05 China and competing economic models 31:23 Can
green investment fix capitalism? 41:35 Economic democracy and essential services 52:17 Money,
debt and changing social relations
#Pascal
Welcome back, everybody, to Neutrality Studies. Today, for the first time, I’m joined by two
European colleagues, Dr. Graziano Ceddia and Dr. Jacopo Bergamo, two researchers affiliated with
the International Society for Critical Social-Ecological Studies, CRISES for short. They work at the
intersection of ecology and Marxism. Graziano, Jacopo, welcome.
#Graziano Ceddia
Thank you. Thank you, Pascal. It's really a pleasure to be here with you.
#Pascal
It's wonderful having you both. And you're super interesting because you're working on, basically,
Marxism and ecology. And we will talk about that in a second. But knowing that both of you are in
-- 1 of 14 --
Europe, I think, Jacopo, let's start with you. You're in Spain. We just have to talk a little bit about all
of the upheaval that's going on right now, all of the protests. What are you observing? What are you
witnessing? And what is the situation like there right now?
#Jacopo Bergamo
Well, I think that what started in France is now spreading, along with a new style of mobilization
that also includes second-generation migrants. It is characterized not by a high level of politicization,
but by a high level of radicalism. And I suspect that this is because of the disintermediation of
society. As we know, in general, here in Europe, left-wing organizations, trade unions, and parties
are not living through their best moments.
However, the rage is high because of living conditions. Here, too, at the center of global capitalism,
societies are at a difficult stage because capital accumulation, as Marx taught us, always undermines
the two sources of wealth: nature and workers. And this is exactly what is happening, in the sense
that living conditions are constantly declining, the cost of living is increasing, and war is a great
threat to our living conditions and to living in peace. It also entails huge costs. There will be cuts in
budget spending across all states.
And here I am in Spain, where there is a special situation because, as maybe most of our listeners
know, Spain probably has the last center-left government in Europe. Despite some shortcomings in
its ability to organize an alternative to the status quo, it has made some important advances, also
symbolically, in recognizing Palestine, opposing Netanyahu’s policies, and denouncing genocide in
Palestine, in Gaza. It has also firmly opposed the increase in military spending to 5% that the U.S. is
asking for. And now Pedro Sánchez, the prime minister, has resigned because of the huge
demonstrations over living conditions, because housing prices are skyrocketing. And there was a
particular incident involving the eviction of Marie Carmen, an 87-year-old lady who was evicted by a
so-called “fondo buitre,” a vulture fund, owned by…
#Graziano Ceddia
A vulture fund. This is a speculative fund.
#Jacopo Bergamo
Exactly. And that led to a huge mobilization in the style of the Indignados movement in 2011. There
are gatherings in squares all over the country. And here, in comparison with France, the
demonstrations are generally very peaceful. So Pedro Sánchez, the leader of PSOE and the current
prime minister, decided to seize this window of opportunity and bring forward the election here in
Spain. There is an opportunity to resist the rise of the right wing and the neo-fascists, because it is
much more favorable to discuss social issues like housing prices instead of the previous topic, the so-
called migrant invasion from Ceuta. So the election will be on the 29th of November. However, we
-- 2 of 14 --
have already seen provocations from the right wing in Bilbao, and we are also starting to see
confrontations with the police in Barcelona. That is not favorable ground for the left to try to win the
election. Let's see what happens, but what is happening in Spain right now is relevant for all of
Europe.
#Pascal
Graziano, just your two cents on the protests that we are seeing. They're really spreading from
France to all sorts of places at the moment. Where do you see this discontent rooted? And as Gioppo
said, part and parcel of it is, of course, the entire economic situation, which is just getting worse and
worse in Europe. Hey, just a very quick note. The best way to support this channel is by signing up
for my free Substack. You can also help with a paid subscription there, or you can get some of our
new merch on neutralitystudies.com. Links below. See you there.
#Graziano Ceddia
Yeah, thank you so much. I would just like to make an introductory remark: here, I'm speaking on
behalf of the association rather than in a personal capacity. And to pick up on what Jacopo said, I
can maybe comment a little bit on what is happening in Italy. Actually, this would also tie in nicely
with the work of the Scientific Association Crisis. In Italy, there have been major demonstrations, for
example, in the south, with blockades set up by logistics workers and farmers. And the reason for
these blockades, which disrupted logistics as a whole and also the delivery of gasoline, for example,
was, of course, the rise in the price of diesel, which massively affects both farmers and logistics
workers.
So here you really see how, if you want, events that may be shaped at a more global level resonate
strongly with what's happening in Italy. And I want to say that what you saw in the media was just
the smashing of some windows at a Gucci shop in Milan. But this was really, I would say, the least
important part of the protests, which have effectively blocked the south of Italy. There were
shortages of fresh fruit, vegetables, milk, and other fresh products in supermarkets in big cities in
the south. And this was seldom spoken of in the media.
So I would say that the issues Jacopo mentioned—the cost of living and quality of life—were really at
the center of these protests. And it's symptomatic that both logistics workers and farmers were the
key initiators of these protests. Because I would say agriculture suffers not only from the rise in the
price of diesel, of course, but also from extreme heat and extreme weather events, which we
experienced over the summer. So you see how, even if you think about the price of diesel and oil,
this already brings in the issue of climate change. So you have, on the one hand, the rise in the cost
of living, which affects certain people disproportionately while benefiting other people
disproportionately.
-- 3 of 14 --
So multinational corporations that sell oil or maybe grains, of course, benefit greatly from the
increase in prices, and they make extra profits in both the oil sector and the food sector. But normal
people, you know, cannot afford to live at the same time. And I would say the same is true for
climate change. Climate change is very beneficial and very profitable for some people, but, you
know, it really impacts the lives of many other people. So both ecological and social questions are
really at the core of the sort of protests that we are seeing.
And I would just like to conclude, maybe, that, you know, what people are demanding is certainly
security, but they want security in the sense of being able to live a decent life. Okay, so they want to
be protected from climate change. They want to be protected from the difficulties of old age, you
know, having the possibility to rely on a healthcare system that works well. They want their children
to be able to go to public schools that are not falling to pieces. So these are, I would say, the
demands of people that fuel these protests and that really have their origins in the ecological and
social questions that are now strongly interlinked. And this is where, I would say, Crisis comes in. It's
an association.
#Pascal
Yeah, let's talk about that a bit more now. So you founded this organization, the International
Society of Critical Social Ecological Studies, with a wonderful acronym, CRISIS. What is your work
about, and how are you approaching this socio-ecological question?
#Jacopo Bergamo
Or how should it be approached?
#Graziano Ceddia
Yeah, maybe I'll just say a few words then, Jakob, if I can. Well, the acronym, you know, was not
easy to find, but eventually we stumbled upon it. I would say that we're witnessing multiple crises:
the ecological crisis in terms of climate change and biodiversity loss, and the extreme levels of
inequality that Oxfam reminds us of every year.
I mean, you don't have to go to Oxfam. Just look at the data from the World Bank, and you will
realize that half of the world population lives on less than $10 per day in purchasing power parity.
And this is not much, you know? Try to live on $10 per day, to pay for accommodation, the bills, the
food, you know, everything. It's impossible. So obviously, you know, there is a problem here. And
we've heard the term “polycrisis” a lot, okay? In itself, it's not bad. It just refers to the fact that
there are multiple crises. But what this term is missing is that possibly there is a single structural
driver of all these crises, both ecological and social.
-- 4 of 14 --
And Marxian analysis is really powerful because it can really unveil the deep structural driver of these
crises. To be honest, I have to say that recently there have been some important contributions. For
example, if you read the 2024 report of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on
Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services, IPBES, it openly talks about root causes and the necessity to
transform our global economic system. Similarly, the sixth assessment report of the IPCC, perhaps in
a more watered-down way, starts to hint at the presence of structural drivers. But I would say that,
in general, the scientific community has not been willing or able to really delve into and unveil those
structural drivers.
And Marxian analysis really has this tremendous capacity to make visible the contradictions of the
process of capital accumulation. And there is this line that Jacopo already mentioned: how, in the
process of capital accumulation, what you experience is the destruction of the sources of value,
which are nature, labor, and humans. So both the social and the ecological aspects, which are the
sources of our wealth and well-being. And so Crisis, as a scientific association, really wants to
provide a space where this debate can be broadened and developed scientifically through the
organization of conferences, providing spaces and opportuniti