Why Many Jews Hate Zionism: The Long History of Jewish Anti-Zionism | Benjamin Moser
Watch this video on YouTube
They are lying to you: Zionism has NOTHING to do with Judaism. It's a protestant British idea and used as much against the jews as it is used against Palestinians.
Benjamin Moser joins Pascal Lottaz to discuss Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History and the diverse Jewish thinkers who opposed Zionism. Moving from rabbis and British politicians to Arab Jewish scholars and contemporary artists, Moser explores religious objections, nationalism, antisemitism, and the promise of safety. They examine settler colonialism, minority rights, Western support for Israel, and changing public opinion. Moser argues that understanding today’s violence requires looking beyond individual leaders to the ideology and historical structures that shaped the Israeli state itself.
Benjamin’s Links:
Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History: https://www.benmoser.com/anti-zionism
English edition: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/770236/anti-zionism-by-benjamin-moser/
German edition: Anti-Zionismus: https://www.ullstein.d
Summary
Benjamin Moser argues that Jewish anti‑Zionism is a long, diverse, and understudied current that decouples Judaism from the political doctrine of Zionism. Tracing figures from an eastern Polish rabbi and Edwin Montagu to Hannah Arendt, Avi Shlaim, Felicia Langer, and contemporary artists, Moser shows how religious, liberal, socialist, feminist, and Third World critiques converged in warning that a Jewish nation‑state would harm both Palestinians and Jews. Early Zionist rhetoric, he contends, often displayed overt anti‑Jewish tropes and a masculinist, violent ideal of the “new Jew” that alarmed rabbis who prized religious endurance and minority rights. Many Jewish dissenters identified Zionism’s settler‑colonial dynamics and rejected the fantasy of an absolute safe haven; Moser emphasizes that liberal remedies (more rights, services) miss the deeper problem of dispossession and structural violence. Understanding current violence, he argues, requires attention to Zionist ideology and institutional histories rather than personalization of leaders.
Article
## Benjamin Moser and Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History
The conversation centers on a difficult but clarifying claim: Zionism and Judaism are not synonymous, and many Jews throughout modern history have actively opposed the Zionist project. This contention matters because the contemporary tendency to equate anti‑Zionism with antisemitism flattens a long tradition of Jewish dissent and silences distinct moral and political analyses. The exchange unpacks that tradition by tracing a wide cast of Jewish voices—rabbis, secular intellectuals, artists, exiles, and politicians—who, for religious, ethical, political, or existential reasons, saw Zionism as a catastrophic redefinition of Jewish life.
The speaker, Benjamin Moser, explains that his book grew out of the urgency provoked by recent events in the Middle East and a worry about how quickly public and legal discourse collapsed nuance. He set out to gather stories of Jews who opposed Zionism from diverse geographies and ideologies, not to repeat familiar polemics but to recover a plurality of Jewish perspectives that have been marginalized, ignored, or intentionally conflated with hostility to Jews as such.
## The Jewish dissenters in the book
The cast of characters Moser reconstructs is deliberately ecumenical. It includes a poor rabbi from a Polish border village who foresaw the communal disasters Zionism would bring; British cabinet ministers like Edwin Montagu who opposed the Balfour Declaration; early Zionists turned critics such as Jacob Israël de Haan; Arab and North African Jewish intellectuals who anticipated the destruction of Jewish life in the Middle East; American Reform congregations that resisted Zionist politicization; and modern figures—lawyers, historians, artists—who have weighed conscience against nationalism.
That variety is not accidental. Moser emphasizes that Jewish anti‑Zionism cannot be reduced to a single ideological strand. It spans religious conservatives who reject secular nationalism, leftists alarmed by colonial and ethnic exclusivism, feminists and queer thinkers critical of Zionist masculinities, and anti‑imperialists who saw Zionism as a settler‑colonial project intertwined with Western power. Each voice brings a different set of reasons, but together they form an extended chorus that has been warning about the costs of a Jewish ethno‑state for over a century.
## Judaism, Zionism, and a shared sensibility
One of the conversation’s more subtle moves is to insist that those varied opponents often speak with a recognizably Jewish sensibility even when their conclusions differ. Moser describes this as a mode of moral perception: a sensitivity to injustice, an identification with the vulnerable, and a habit of critical distance that sometimes amounts to a conscious embrace of outsider status. Whether the objection arises from Talmudic devotion to law, a secular commitment to universalism, or a minority politics of solidarity, the tone and ethical priorities often reflect a common cultural formation.
This shared sensibility helps explain why many Jewish critics of Zionism address issues differently than non‑Jewish critics. Their arguments do not come from detachment or facile oppositionality but from lived traditions—religious texts, diasporic experiences, histories of persecution—that shape how they conceive safety, dignity, and communal survival. Recognizing that internal plurality undercuts the caricature that sees any Jewish critique of Israel as a betrayal or as evidence of self‑hatred. Instead, it restores dissent to its place as a historically continuous and distinctively Jewish form of political engagement.
## Antisemitism, Herzl, and the “new Jew”
The conversation turns candid about an uncomfortable truth: many early Zionist thinkers expressed contempt for Jewish religious life and even used anti‑Jewish tropes as part of their rhetoric. The founder figures’ language often mixes self‑critique with the kind of cultural disdain that in other contexts would be read as self‑destructive. Moser recounts how Herzl and contemporaries described Jews in deeply derogatory terms, promissory of a “new Jew” who would shed perceived passivity for muscular, modern nationhood.
This self‑reformist impulse had an appeal: for Jews suffering discrimination in parts of Europe, the promise of dignity through strength and sovereignty resonated. At the same time, its built‑in contempt for diasporic religious life alienated rabbis and other custodians of Jewish tradition. For critics in Moser’s narrative, Zionism’s attempt to remake Jewish identity through state violence and masculinized heroism was not merely a political alternative but a repudiation of what sustained Jewish communal and ethical life for centuries.
## The rabbis’ objections to violence
Religious objections run deep and practical in the account. For many rabbis, Judaism’s notion of heroism and communal value is bound up with study, law, and ethical submission to a transcendent moral order. The courage Judaism prizes is often inward and legal, not martial. Thus, the Zionist valorization of force and territorial conquest violated fundamental theological and moral horizons.
Moser highlights figures like Aaron Samuel Tamares, who argued early on that pursuing a secular, forceful state would endanger both Palestinians and Jews. Their critique was not nostalgic conservatism but a sober reading of history: empires that wield violence vanish, while persecuted communities often outlive their oppressors. To these religious critics, Jewish survival had been secured historically by adaptive resilience, ethical particularism, and legal discipline—not by attempting to master the world through arms.
The rabbis’ alarm also exposes a deeper anxiety: that adopting state violence as a defining instrument risks transforming the moral character of the Jewish people. If survival is pursued through power over others, the ethical center of a tradition forged under persecution could be hollowed out in the name of security.
## Safety, statehood, and minority rights
Another major theme is the tradeoffs embedded in the demand for a Jewish state. For many Jewish anti‑Zionists, the promise of safety through territorial sovereignty was illusory or pyrrhic. Statehood, especially of an ethno‑national kind, solves some immediate security dilemmas but generates others: dispossession of another people, the suppression of minority rights, and a dependence on external powers for legitimacy. Moser and the conversation’s interlocutors detail how Zionist statecraft relied on imperial patronage, demographic engineering, and exclusionary legal frameworks that ultimately threatened the very communal flourishing it sought to guarantee.
The objection is also pragmatic: Jews in many liberal societies had attained civil rights and integration by the twentieth century; framing statehood as the only path to safety ignored alternatives and weaponized Jewish victimhood for geopolitical ends. Critics saw that the state’s logic would require institutional mechanisms of dominance and militarization, which would entangle Jews in cycles of violence and delegitimation rather than extricate them from danger.
## Settler colonialism and historical comparisons
A recurrent and decisive claim in the exchange is that Zionism, as practiced, bears structural affinities with settler colonialisms elsewhere. That is to say, the project involved a political settlement in which a foreign‑backed national community established control over territory populated by indigenous people. Moser traces how British imperial designs, demographic displacements, and the creation of a ruling majority produced patterns familiar from other colonial contexts: land appropriation, asymmetrical legal regimes, and the subordination of an indigenous population.
Crucially, invoking settler colonialism is not a moralizing slur but an analytical category that clarifies stakes and mechanisms. It shows why
Transcript
Why Many Jews Hate Zionism: The Long
History of Jewish Anti-Zionism | Benjamin
Moser
They are lying to you: Zionism has NOTHING to do with Judaism. It's a protestant British idea and
used as much against the jews as it is used against Palestinians. Benjamin Moser joins Pascal Lottaz
to discuss Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History and the diverse Jewish thinkers who opposed Zionism.
Moving from rabbis and British politicians to Arab Jewish scholars and contemporary artists, Moser
explores religious objections, nationalism, antisemitism, and the promise of safety. They examine
settler colonialism, minority rights, Western support for Israel, and changing public opinion. Moser
argues that understanding today’s violence requires looking beyond individual leaders to the ideology
and historical structures that shaped the Israeli state itself. Benjamin’s Links: Anti-Zionism: A Jewish
History: https://www.benmoser.com/anti-zionism English edition: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.
com/books/770236/anti-zionism-by-benjamin-moser/ German edition: Anti-Zionismus: https://www.
ullstein.de/werke/anti-zionismus/hardcover/9783549100912 International editions: https://www.
benmoser.com/international-editions Benjamin’s Substack: https://benjaminmoser.substack.com
Neutrality Studies Links: Neutrality Studies Substack: https://pascallottaz.substack.com Support
Neutrality Studies: https://neutralitystudies.com/donate Neutrality Studies shop:
https://neutralitystudies.com/shop Time Stamps 00:00 Benjamin Moser and Anti-Zionism: A Jewish
History 03:42 The Jewish dissenters in the book 08:00 Judaism, Zionism, and a shared sensibility 12:
44 Antisemitism, Herzl, and the “new Jew” 18:53 The rabbis’ objections to violence 22:46 Safety,
statehood, and minority rights 26:23 Settler colonialism and historical comparisons 39:45 Public
opinion and the limits of changing leaders
#Pascal
Welcome back, everybody, to Neutrality Studies. Today, I’m joined for the first time by Benjamin
Moser, an American writer and researcher who recently wrote the wonderful book *Anti-Zionism: A
Jewish History*. Benjamin, welcome. Thanks so much. Well, thank you for saying yes to this, and
thank you for writing this book. You are one of the latest authors who have thrown themselves into
this arena of trying to disentangle Zionism from Judaism. I just want to point out that my dear friend
and colleague Yakov Rabkin, who wrote *Zionism Decoded in 101 Quotes*, is also going in a similar
direction. You’re going in that direction, and I really want to discuss this with you and explore your
approach, because you’re doing it in a very specific manner in your book. Can you maybe tell us first
a little bit about why you decided to write this book, and then how you approached the subject?
#Benjamin Moser
-- 1 of 14 --
I decided to write the book, actually, after October 7th. I mean, I was working on a completely
different book, and actually, I was doing pretty well with it. I was deep into it, and I was enjoying it.
And then October 7th happened. And if you knew this issue, you knew exactly what was going to
happen. You knew that Israel was going to lose its marbles and start murdering tens of thousands of
people. I don't know that anyone thought it would become quite this bad. But if you knew anything
about this question and about this region, you knew this was going to happen. And so, towards the
end of 2023, the conflation of Judaism and Zionism, of Jews and Israel, started becoming extremely
aggressive and was even being given the force of law.
You know, in the United States Congress, they passed this resolution saying that anti-Zionism is anti-
Semitism. And this is just such obvious bullshit. If you know anything about the Palestinian
movement, if you know how many Jews are involved in this, how many Jews are losing their jobs
over this and being threatened over this, you know that it's just a ridiculous equation. But
nonetheless, it's an equation that has a lot of plausibility for people who don't know much about the
question. And it also has plausibility for Zionists who do know about this question but who are
always dissimulating and always pretending not to.
So I thought, I have to do this book, even though I didn't know what this book was, because, you
know, Palestine, Israel, Zionism—it's like the most written-about subject in the whole world. So you
don't want to just repeat things. You want to contribute something new. And I thought that what I
could contribute was telling the stories of Jewish people who opposed Zionism, and why, and from
what different angles. So I wanted to do it as broadly as possible. So not just, you know,
Ashkenazic, European, American people, but people from Africa, people from the Arab world, people
from Latin America, from different times, from different perspectives.
Just because of my own background, I'm more familiar with left-wing objections to Zionism. But in
fact, there are a lot of very interesting right-wing objections to Zionism. There are objections to
Zionism from the perspective of the Third World. There are objections to Zionism from the
perspective of feminism. There are objections from the perspective of religion and of atheism and of
communism. I mean, it's quite amazing how diverse these people are, but they all agree that this is
a disaster. And they've been saying this for a century, and nobody's listened to them.
#Pascal
Can you give us a short list of the people who appear in your book, whose stories you trace to show
their objections to Zionism?
#Benjamin Moser
Well, it starts with a rabbi in eastern Poland at the end of the 19th century, Aaron Samuel Tamares,
who was a guy who lived in a little village in the eastern part of Poland. It's now on the border with
Belarus. It was a town of 600 people, about half Jewish, half not Jewish. And this rabbi figured out
-- 2 of 14 --
almost immediately that this was going to lead to a disaster, not only for the Palestinians, but for the
Jews themselves. And then I go from this little muddy village to a great palace in London, the heart
of the British Empire. And I tell the story of two cousins: Edwin Montagu, who's the only Jew in the
British cabinet at the time of the adoption of the Balfour Declaration, and his really despicable
cousin, Herbert Samuel, who becomes the first governor of British Mandatory Palestine in 1919. And
then, from there, I go on to tell the story.
So that's about the Balfour Declaration. Then I go to the beginning of the Mandate, when a
homosexual Dutch poet named Jacob Israël de Haan comes to Palestine as a Zionist. And, to make a
long story short, they murder him. And from there, I go to Cairo, to Ahmed Sadiq Saad, who is an
Egyptian communist who understands exactly what's going on in Palestine and understands how it
relates to Egypt and how it's going to destroy the Jewish communities of the Arab world, which, of
course, it does. And then from Cairo, I go to Houston, which is where I was born. And I tell the story
of a split in the largest synagogue in the American South in 1943 over the question of Zionism. And
that's also to tell the story of why Reform Jews in America, who make up the largest American
Jewish group, opposed Zionism.
And then from there, I go to Baghdad. I tell the story of Avi Shlaim, who is a great British academic
who grows up in the Israeli state and is slowly but surely radicalized over a long period of time. He
says he was “radicalized in the archives.” I tell the story of the origins of the Israeli state, and also
the story of what happens to the Arab Jews. So, just as Sadiq Saad warns about this, Avi Shlaim
lives through it as a little boy. And then from there, I go to—I'm not sure if I'm going to get it right—
Hannah Arendt, and I tell the story of Zionist involvement with Nazism, which is the ultimate third
rail when you're talking about Zionism. I talk about Felicia Langer, the Israeli lawyer who becomes
the first lawyer to defend the Palestinians. I tell about Helena Salem, who's a Brazilian journalist.
I tell about Ronnie Kasrils, a South African freedom fighter. Let me see. And then I end with Nan
Goldin, an American artist who experiences what she calls the Holocaust, which is the genocide in
Gaza. So I think I'm missing somebody, actually, but, you know, it's a pretty broad range of people.
I am really trying to include as many voices as possible, also because I want people from different
backgrounds. I think Jewish people feel really alone when they discover just how twisted and
disgraceful a cause they've been enlisted in, almost without knowing that they were being enlisted.
And that was my case. I grew up in a very soft Zionist world. And it's really disturbing to come
across the long, almost unbroken list of crimes and cruelties that Zionism has brought with it.
#Pascal
Hey, just a very quick note. The best way to support this channel is by signing up for my free
Substack. You can also help with a paid subscription there, or you can get some of our new merch
on neutralitystudies.com. Links below. See you there. What is it that connects all of these very
different cases of opposition to the Zionist project? And just for everybody who's listening, before we
get deep into the weeds, the most fundamental difference between Judaism and Zionism is, of
-- 3 of 14 --
course, that Judaism is a religion. Zionism is a political cause. It's a political movement. And that, in
and of itself, is nothing bad.
There are a lot of different political movements out there that want political things. Fine. But the
Zionist movement is, of course, the aspiration to create a Jewish state for Jews only, or for Jews as
an absolute majority who rule over everybody else. That's the political goal. That has nothing to do
with the religion of Judaism itself in the first place, but the conflation has been that one is the other,
and if you don't like the political cause, then you don't like the Jews, which is exactly what a lot of
these people oppose. But I think they came to that position from different starting points in their
reasoning. Something unites them, or must unite them. What is that?
#Benjamin Moser
Well, I think it's a sensibility. I mean, when I wrote my book about Susan Sontag, I wrote a lot
about “Notes on Camp,” which is this famous essay she wrote in the early ’60s. And “Notes on
Camp” was originally called “Notes on Homosexuality,” and she changed the title. But it's kind of
about what a gay sensibility is. So you can usually tell if somebody's gay, right? You're not supposed
to be able to tell if someone's gay, according to political correctness, but, you know, you can usually
tell. I live in the Netherlands. When I came to this country many years ago, I thought it was really
weird that the Dutch could instantly tell who was Dutch and who was Belgian, you know.
You're Swiss, right? I mean, you can tell the difference between Swiss people and French people.
You can just see it. But if I said, “Describe what you're seeing between Swiss people and Germans,”
you know, you can see it, but it's hard to describe. I can now spot a Dutch person from, like, 2,000
meters away. If I'm in Tibet, I can tell somebody's Dutch immediately. I don't know why. You can
see it. You can see Americans miles away. And I think that you can also see Jews. There's
something that's kind of hard to describe. Like, I couldn't say exactly, “It's this,” or “It's that,” or “It's
this.” But there is such a thing as a Jewish sensibility.
There is such a thing as a Jewish way of thinking and talking. Of course, it doesn't apply to
everybody everywhere. But you can generalize. And even though these people are very different, I
think what brings them together is not only this issue, but the way they approach it, which is very
distinctly Jewish. There's something in the voice. You know, I was talking the other night about
Brazilian Jews. My first book was about Clarice Lispector, and I was talking about going to the