German Professor: The EU is FINISHED. What's Next? | Dr. Ulrike Guérot

Watch this video on YouTube

The European Union has become a complete bureaucratic and authoritarian monster, and it is impossible to fix. It must and will die. But what comes next? The continent will still be there. Professor Ulrike Guérot joins Pascal to discuss her new (German) book "Endlich Europa!" and a possible Europe beyond the European Union. She proposes a European republic combining equal citizenship, autonomous regions and limited shared institutions. Their conversation explores republicanism, democracy, infrastructure, sovereignty and the tensions within the single market and euro. Lottaz challenges her proposal with an ASEAN-style alternative, while Guérot argues that existing economic integration demands a different political framework. Together they consider Europe’s place in an emerging multipolar world. Ulrike's Links: Endlich Europa! — book and multilingual resources: https://endlich-europa.eu Neutrality Studies Links: Neutrality Studies Substack: https://pascallottaz.substack.com Support Neu

Summary

Ulrike Guérot argues that the European Union has become a dysfunctional technocracy and proposes replacing it with a European republic that embeds the single market and euro within a democratic, social commonwealth. Drawing on republican thought from Aristotle to Kant, she distinguishes “republic” (res publica) from mere electoral democracy and emphasizes institutions that serve the common good rather than oligarchic interests. Her 2045 vignette envisages autonomous, identity-based regions (roughly optimal at 10–15 million people) regaining most domestic competencies, while a thin European level retains coordination over foreign and trade policy, macro‑infrastructure, and public goods such as cross‑continental transport and AI. Guérot frames this as a response to the EU’s democratic deficit, socioeconomic fragmentation, and strategic weakness in a multipolar world, arguing that political reconfiguration—regional autonomy within a federating republic—better reconciles local identities with the need for collective sovereignty and equitable economic governance.

Article

## The Crisis of the EU and the Need for a New Image The conversation with Dr. Ulrike Guérot begins from a blunt diagnosis: the European Union, as currently constituted, is not merely imperfect; it has become a bureaucratic and political organism that fails the citizens it was meant to serve. That diagnosis is rooted in observable economic stagnation, social dislocation, and the geopolitical squeeze exerted by a more contested global order. But Guérot does not stop at critique. Her central move is constructive: to offer an image—less a detailed blueprint than a persuasive political imagination—of a Europe that survives the EU without falling back to narrow nationalism. The image matters because political futures are often opened by compelling metaphors; in her case the phoenix rising from ashes serves as both an analytic and rhetorical anchor for imagining Europe after the EU. This framing is intentionally provocative. Guérot wants to dislodge complacency—not merely to argue that the EU is broken but to insist that neither technocratic tinkering nor nativist retrenchment will restore a common political life on the continent. The ambition she stakes out is not to reconstitute the same machinery under a different brand, but to re-center political life around the notion of the res publica: a shared public good and a republic that places citizens, and their collective welfare, at the heart of institutional design. ## Republic over Technocracy: Reviving Res Publica A key conceptual shift in Guérot’s argument is the elevation of “republic” over the narrower, proceduralist language of “democracy” or the institutional vocabulary of “federalism.” Drawing on the longue durée of European political thought—from classical antiquity through Kant—she revives the older idea of res publica as the commonwealth, the public wealth that binds political collectives together. Republic, in this sense, is not merely about elections or majoritarian procedures; it is about orienting public institutions and economic arrangements toward the common good. That distinction matters because much of the current malaise stems from the EU’s form: a system that privileges regulatory integration and market harmonization while leaving the social and political foundations of public life thin and fragmented. Guérot contends that democracy as a method (elections, procedural rules) cannot substitute for a substantive republican project that embeds social protection, representation, and public investment in a shared political architecture. In short, reclaiming the language of the republic reframes the debate from technocratic governance to normative political purpose: what institutions are for, and whom they serve. ## Embedding Market and Currency in Political Union One of the most striking claims in the discussion is how painfully incomplete European integration has been. The single market and the euro bind people and firms across borders, but they were never accompanied by the political and fiscal instruments necessary to make that integration socially sustainable. Guérot labels this lacuna absurd: a continental market and shared currency without a commensurate democratic framework, fiscal union, or capacity for collective infrastructure and industrial policy. This structural mismatch has predictable consequences. Economic liberalization across unequal social spaces produced dislocations: shrinking social protections, regional inequalities, and a rural–urban divide. Those material grievances have fed political fragmentation and the rise of populists and reactionary forces. Guérot’s proposal is to make the political architecture congruent with economic integration—essentially to build a republican framework that can legitimately and effectively steward a shared market and currency. Without that, the current setup becomes a vector of discontent rather than an instrument of common prosperity. ## Regions, Identities, and the Scale of Sovereignty If the republic is to be meaningful, it must reckon with the reality that Europe is not neatly composed of 27 homogeneous nation-states. Guérot pushes the reader to think historically and spatially: borders have shifted, identities overlap, and many sub-state regions possess coherent political cultures—Brittany, Tyrol, Catalonia, and others. The challenge is how to create a political framework that respects sub-national identities and regional autonomy while enabling collective decision-making at a broader European level. Her approach does not require erasing nationhood or imposing top-down uniformity. Rather, she imagines a multi-scalar republican polity in which equal citizenship is guaranteed across the continent while autonomy for regions is institutionalized. The aim is a plural, layered sovereignty: people would retain local, regional, and national ties, but these would be nested within a European citizenship that confers rights, obligations, and a voice in common affairs. Such an arrangement seeks to sidestep the false choice between atomized nation-states and a homogenizing superstate by framing political community around shared public goods and democratic participation at multiple levels. ## Institutions, Subsidiarity, and Infrastructure Designing institutions for this republic raises concrete questions: what powers are exercised centrally, which responsibilities are local, and how are conflicts mediated? Guérot draws on the principle of subsidiarity—not as an empty slogan but as a governing rule to allocate authority where it is most effective. Crucially, she emphasizes that subsidiarity must be accompanied by capacity-building: local governments need resources and competencies to fulfill their mandates, and a European level must retain the ability to coordinate transnational infrastructure, industrial policy, and social protections. Infrastructure is a linchpin in this argument. Europe lacks a mechanism to plan and fund large-scale projects that span borders—transport corridors, energy grids, digital backbone—because political authority and financial capacity remain fragmented. A republican framework would enable pooled resources and democratic oversight for investments that are genuinely common. That, in turn, would address the rural–urban gap by channeling development where it is socially necessary rather than allowing market forces alone to determine outcomes. ## Alternatives: ASEAN-style Confederation versus a European Republic The conversation anticipates another pathway: an ASEAN-style confederation where sovereign states cooperate loosely without yielding deeper political integration. That model has appeal for those wary of centralized power—but Guérot pushes back, arguing that the EU’s economic entanglement demands a different political logic. A thin confederation might preserve formal sovereignty but would leave citizens exposed to transnational market dynamics without adequate democratic control or social buffers. The trade-off here is between flexibility and capacity. Looser cooperation can be nimble, but it cannot deliver the coordinated fiscal policies, collective investments, or social protections needed to stabilize a deeply integrated economic space. Guérot’s republican alternative is offered as a synthesis: not a monolith but a polity capable of concerted action, equitable redistribution, and democratic legitimacy—features a mere confederation cannot reliably provide when markets and currencies operate at a continental scale. ## The Euro, Neutrality, and Europe's Place in a Multipolar World Finally, the euro looms large as both a symptom and a driver of the EU’s dilemmas. A common currency implies common interests and shared liabilities, yet without shared fiscal instruments and democratic accountability it becomes a source of division. Guérot’s republican prescription would embed the euro within a political architecture that can manage monetary and fiscal policy in tandem, and that can distribute the burde

Transcript

German Professor: The EU is FINISHED. What's Next? | Dr. Ulrike Guérot The European Union has become a complete bureaucratic and authoritarian monster, and it is impossible to fix. It must and will die. But what comes next? The continent will still be there. Professor Ulrike Guérot joins Pascal to discuss her new (German) book "Endlich Europa!" and a possible Europe beyond the European Union. She proposes a European republic combining equal citizenship, autonomous regions and limited shared institutions. Their conversation explores republicanism, democracy, infrastructure, sovereignty and the tensions within the single market and euro. Lottaz challenges her proposal with an ASEAN-style alternative, while Guérot argues that existing economic integration demands a different political framework. Together they consider Europe’s place in an emerging multipolar world. Ulrike's Links: Endlich Europa! — book and multilingual resources: https://endlich-europa.eu Neutrality Studies Links: Neutrality Studies Substack: https://pascallottaz.substack.com Support Neutrality Studies: https://neutralitystudies.com /donate Neutrality Studies shop: https://neutralitystudies.com/shop Time Stamps 00:00 Ulrike Guérot: imagining Europe after the EU 04:12 What a republic means 12:47 The single market and Europe’s political deficit 17:51 Regions, identities and equal citizenship 24:30 Who makes the rules in a European republic 33:30 Subsidiarity, infrastructure and the rural divide 39:43 An ASEAN-style alternative for Europe 48:37 The euro, sovereignty and Europe’s future #Pascal Welcome back, everybody, to Neutrality Studies. Today, we have an update with the wonderful German academic Professor Ulrike Guérot. Ulrike, welcome back. #Ulrike Guérot Pascal, welcome. Happy to be here. #Pascal Very happy that we can talk online again. Last time, two weeks ago, you were in Kyoto. But today, we said we were going to talk about your new book. It has a German title, but translated, it means “Finally Europe: How the European Republic Will Become Reality,” or something along those lines. So the book is out in German. Anyone who speaks German can get it online or in bookstores in Germany or German-speaking Europe. But we're going to discuss it today in English so a few more people can get some information. And if there's an interested publisher, maybe somebody will -- 1 of 18 -- approach you about an English version. But for now, Ulrike, “Finally Europe”—at a time when we all trash-talk the European Union, including you, because I think you've also lost your belief in it. What do you mean by “Finally Europe”? #Ulrike Guérot Well, I mean, I have no problem admitting that perhaps I wrote this book only for myself, because I could see that Europe is looking into the abyss and is basically in a clash with its own civilization and culture. It is in very, very bad shape. I mean, we do not need to discuss on this channel the socioeconomic downturn of Europe, the geostrategic challenges, Europe being squeezed and basically instrumentalized in this war between Ukraine and Russia, you know? So I guess the people on this channel know all this. So why did I seize this moment in time, this sort of dark moment for Europe, to write a utopia? Basically, the book is set in 2045, and it's a little book about how we can pull a Europe after the EU— that is the important point, a Europe after the EU—out of the ashes, like a phoenix out of the ashes, right? And perhaps I wrote it only for myself because I experienced better times in the 1990s. I worked for former EU Commission President Jacques Delors. I was deeply engaged in Franco- German relations in the time of Jean-Claude Juncker and Jacques Delors and Mitterrand and Kohl, who were all war children and who, in the '80s, had a heartfelt ambition to build a democratic, social, peaceful Europe, just because they were war children. I think I can say that because I knew most of these people. So when I speak, obviously I have my memories of the '80s and the early '90s, before the European project was hijacked, distorted, and perverted into what it is today: a technocracy, a bureaucracy, and increasingly authoritarian. I think I need to say this up front. But the emotional part of it is: can we still create some hope? I mean, what I wanted to do with the book is—you know, there is a saying in German: when the night is darkest… What is “Dämmerung”? Dawn. Dawn. #Ulrike Guérot The dawn is near. And I'm deeply convinced that at some point you just need an image. I wouldn't even say a vision or a utopia, but just an image of how it could be. And that's what I wanted to deliver with the book: an image of what a different Europe could look like. #Pascal In the talk you gave here in Kyoto, you spoke very passionately about the need to build a European republic. The talk is online as well; you can find it in the video section of this channel. And I think it’s in the subtitle of this book here—the European Republic is there. How do you envision a working, functioning European republic that is not this EU bureaucratic monster, whatever it is, that’s currently putting out its tentacles and trying to suffocate everybody? -- 2 of 18 -- #Ulrike Guérot Well, I mean, first I should say that I wrote another book in 2016, so 10 years ago: Why Europe Should Become a Republic: A Political Utopia. And this book is, by the way, still available in English on Amazon. It has been translated into, I guess, seven languages, including English, Polish, Dutch, and Italian. So it was quite a success 10 years ago. And that is important, because in 2016, we were experiencing the first term of Donald Trump. It was the end of the liberal order. Brexit happened. And there was already this sentiment that we cannot go on with the EU, which is this sort of monstrous political body. But we do not want this sort of populist, nationalist regression. And with the utopia of a European republic, I wanted to offer something in between, you know—the tertium non datur, the supposedly excluded third option. So I’m coming back to this 10 years after 2016, in 2026, right? And first of all, I just wanted to remind everybody that the notion, the term “republic,” right, is the word we use when it comes to constituting political order. Since Plato, Aristotle, and Cicero, we haven’t been talking about the nation-state or the sovereign state, or even about the state, but about the republic. And so “republic” is the oldest word in European history, going back to Plato’s Politeia, that we use when it comes to organizing citizens’ lives together, right? The political life of citizens, right? And it has a really long political history, because, again, you come to Jean Bodin in the 16th century, with Les Six Livres de la République, The Six Books of the Republic. Then you go to Kant, who was always talking about the republic. You know, if you read Kant, the first paragraph of his Zum ewigen Frieden, his perpetual peace project, says that only a republican constitution is a good constitution, right? So there is a lot in this word, and I wanted to apply this word. #Pascal Let's talk about the word first, because I think it's worth distinguishing it from other words like democracy or federalism. Res publica, if I remember correctly, means the thing of the public, right? The public good, right? Why is it, then, that this concept has been with us for 2,400 years? And what exactly should we imagine when we talk about this concept in its purest form? #Ulrike Guérot I mean, first we should realize that most current states are republics, you know, be it the Chinese People's Republic, the Republic of Korea, the German Republic, or the French Republic. You know, most states have the word “republic” in their names. We don't call ourselves the German Democracy, Bundesdemokratie Deutschland, or the French Democracy. It's the French Republic and the Italian Republic. It's not trivial that we kept the notion of “republic” in our state names, right? Because what you are saying is the essence: it should be an order, a public order, which is good for the public, meaning res publica, meaning good for everybody, right? -- 3 of 18 -- And when the notion of republic was first translated, in, I think, 1647, through the Putney Papers, and came into the early English discussions about, you know, representative parliamentarism, John Locke, and so on, “republic” was, interestingly, translated as “commonwealth.” Today, we understand the Commonwealth as the British Empire, but commonwealth is basically the wealth of everybody, the common wealth that we share. And from this, you can come up with phrases like “no taxation without representation,” because it's our commonwealth. The people who form the republic—everything that they work for or create is their common wealth. And then: no taxation without representation. We own this, right? #Pascal Hey, just a very quick note. The best way to support this channel is by signing up for my free Substack. You can also help with a paid subscription there, or you can get some of our new merch on neutralitystudies.com. Links below. See you there. #Ulrike Guérot And in essence—and that is important today, I think, when we talk a lot about, say, a post-liberal order—the republic is basically not compatible with, say, oligarchic structures, because oligarchic structures are squeezing people out. They are taking the surplus. They are taking it away from people. And this is a very current discussion. We have Pilkington's book, The End of the Global Liberal Order. And that is why I argue Europe must become a republic, because we need to go back to what is good for our people and the res publica europaea. So, create a political system that would be good for all European citizens, rather than an EU system that is not good for European citizens. #Pascal So what you mean is we need to create a political structure that is a political commonwealth, a public order that serves the people and everybody in it. And that basic idea should then inform the vision of how to create more concrete political structures inside that future Europe. Is that it? #Ulrike Guérot Yeah, I will answer with two points. The first, just to repeat, when we go back to Aristotle and look at the typology of governing systems from Aristotle to Kant, the typology is not that a monarchy is bad and a democracy is good because everybody participates. Rather, Aristotle distinguishes between public orders that are good for the people and those that are not good for the people. But whether one governs, a few govern, or all govern is not the decisive criterion for Aristotle. So that means Aristotle says if a king governs for the good of all the people, he is a good king. If he doesn't govern for the good of all people, he's a tyrant. If an aristocracy does something good for all people, like, say, the Medicis, who built hospitals and financed art and Leonardo da Vinci, it's a -- 4 of 18 -- good aristocracy. If it's an oligarchy and the oligarchy is just squeezing the people, like today's oligarchy, then it's a bad oligarchy. It's not good for all the people. And then there's politeia in Plato, you know. If all govern, but for the good of the res publica, it's a republic, the republican order, which has within it an economic model that must be good for all people. But if it does not apply this, then it's a democracy. So, in Aristotelian typology, tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy are the three bad types of government. And in a way, monarchy, aristocracy, and republic are the three good types of government. And this is why I wanted to bring the word “republic” back into our consciousness, because today we are in a time when everybody wants to save democracy. And the essence is that democracy is, first and foremost, a method. We have elections, so it's democracy. Yeah. But a republic is more than elections. It's not only a form, but it also has content. And the content is res pu