They are lying to you about the Russia's supposed "Hybrid War". The question is why are they lying? To transform the entire EU into the next mega Ukraine? To back save their own power? To create mass-hysteria? Or all of the above?
Thomas Fazi joins Pascal to debunk claims of Russian hybrid warfare in Europe. Drawing on his recent investigation, Fazi questions the evidence behind prominent sabotage allegations, drone scares and media coverage. They discuss the Leipzig airport case, political incentives, defence industry interests and the distinction between propaganda and collective fear. The conversation also explores censorship, civil liberties and historical parallels, while warning that escalating threat narratives could contribute to a real confrontation between NATO and Russia, with dangerous consequences.
Thomas's Links:
Substack: https://www.thomasfazi.com/
The Russian hybrid war narrative — full article: https://www.thomasfazi.com/p/the-russian-hybrid-war-narrative
Responsibl
Article
## Deflating the Hybrid War Narrative
A persistent drumbeat has grown into a chorus: Europe is under siege from Russian “hybrid warfare.” The conversation with Thomas Fazi reframes that chorus as a strategic cascade of recurring, weakly supported allegations rather than a coherent, evidence-backed campaign. Fazi’s investigation does not assert that state-on-state sabotage is impossible — only that the public record, as it stands, overwhelmingly documents a pattern of sensational claims, selective reporting, and sparse proof. In short: the story we are repeatedly told about a deliberate, sustained Russian campaign to undermine Europe’s infrastructure and public life requires far more scrutiny than it has been afforded.
Fazi’s central claim is crisp: modern propaganda thrives not on one spectacular lie but on many small, plausible-sounding assertions that accumulate as background noise. Each is presented with the rhetorical weight of “allegedly,” amplified by officials or intelligence sources, and repeated incessantly until the public’s default assumption becomes guilt by association. Even when individual allegations are debunked, the corrections are tiny ripples beside the tidal waves of initial headlines. That structural asymmetry — heavy, immediate claims; light, delayed refutations — is the engine that keeps the hybrid-war narrative running.
## Cataloguing the Claims and Debunkings
One of the most useful contributions from Fazi’s investigation is its ambition to assemble a counter-database: a systematic showing of claimed incidents and the evidence (or lack thereof) that links them to Russian actors. He traces the narrative back to the escalation around and after 2022, when allegations of sabotage, drone attacks, cyber intrusions and mysterious fires began circulating with increasing frequency. What emerges is not a parade of proven operations, but rather a sequence of incidents that, on closer inspection, tend to unravel into mundane explanations.
Take the undersea cables in the Baltic: initial media and political speculation pointed at deliberate sabotage, implicitly or explicitly blaming Russia. Subsequent investigations, however, identified a far more prosaic cause — collisions with commercial ships flagged to China and Hong Kong. The DHL cargo crash in Lithuania and the electrical substation fire that briefly shut down a major UK airport were both, upon deeper inquiry, traced to pilot error and poor maintenance respectively. These are not exotic modes of attack; they are familiar industrial and human failures miscast as state-directed sabotage.
The drone panic that gripped parts of Europe furnishes another instructive example. When dozens of “sightings” were reported around airports and military installations, investigators later found that many of those sightings were conventional aircraft, helicopters, satellites or misidentified stars — and where drones were confirmed, many were hobbyists or innocuous commercial devices. The pattern repeats: a dramatic headline, official insinuation, public alarm, then a modest, often obscured retraction or clarification.
## The Leipzig Airport Case and Standards of Proof
Not all incidents are equally weak. Leipzig’s summer drone episode is rightly treated as an exceptional case precisely because the German authorities issued a formal attribution to actors they tied to the Russian state. Here, the stakes are higher: the allegation is an attempted explosive attack on an airport used to stage military logistics. For consequential claims like this, the public interest demands clarity: what evidence exists, who collected it, and how was attribution established?
Fazi stresses that a credible attribution process must be transparent enough to allow independent assessment, even if some technical details remain classified. Blanket claims that “we cannot reveal the sources because it would compromise intelligence” are insufficient when those claims could influence electoral politics, public opinion, and military posture. The timing of Leipzig — hyped weeks before regional elections — combined with an absence of shared evidence, magnified public distrust. If the authorities do possess solid forensic linkage to foreign actors, the logical remedy is to present whatever can responsibly be shared so citizens can judge the plausibility of an escalation narrative.
There is a second danger here: the normalizing of attribution without evidence conditions publics to accept future allegations uncritically. Political leaders and media outlets that habitually attribute incidents to hostile states without demonstrable proof risk making escalation more likely, because once an allegation has been internalized by electorates, strategic pressure to “do something” rises.
## Media Incentives, Political Gains and Defence Industry Interests
Understanding why the hybrid narrative proliferates requires attention to incentives. Newsrooms favor sensationalism because attention is a scarce commodity; stories of sabotage and stealthy drones command clicks and airtime. Politicians benefit too: alarmist narratives make the case for tougher security measures, higher defense spending, and enhanced authority for security services. For political leaders seeking to consolidate power or to mobilize electorates, a persistent external threat is useful.
Fazi also draws attention to a less discussed actor: the defense industry. Rearmament programs and expanded procurement follow neatly from heightened threat perceptions. When governments and publics believe they face a rapidly evolving menace, the path to increased budgets and new weaponry becomes politically easy. This alignment of media dynamics, political utility, and industry benefit creates a self-reinforcing ecosystem in which narratives that justify more spending and more authority have disproportionate staying power, irrespective of evidentiary rigor.
Moreover, anonymous intelligence leaks and off-the-record briefings serve this system well. They allow officials to seed alarming claims while avoiding direct responsibility if they are later discredited. The result is that public debate is shaped less by verifiable facts than by strategic storytelling calibrated to move policy levers.
## Cognitive Warfare, Civil Liberties and Risk of Escalation
Beyond incentives, the conversation highlights a conceptual shift: the conflation of propaganda, surveillance, and security into a new lexicon of “cognitive warfare.” Under this rubric, fostering fear and disorientation is treated as an act of aggression potentially as damaging as kinetic strikes. That is a legitimate concern — psychological operations do matter in modern conflict — but the label must not become a catch-all that criminalizes dissent or normalizes broad censorship.
Fazi warns that exaggerated external-threat narratives can erode civil liberties at home. When publics accept the need for extraordinary measures to counter an amorphous hybrid threat, restrictions on speech, increased surveillance, and militarized policing can follow quickly and with little democratic oversight. History offers numerous examples where fear of external enemies was used to compress civic space. The present trend risks importing those dynamics into European democracies at a time when healthy scrutiny is most needed.
A second and graver risk is strategic: repeatedly framing ambiguous incidents as hostile acts by a foreign power raises the likelihood of miscalculation. If an actor believes that a rival state is already conducting sabotage on its soil, it is more likely to respond with assertive—and potentially escalatory—measures. Thus, a fog of false positives can become the prelude to real confrontation. By inflating threat perceptions without corresponding transparency, policymakers may inadvertently move Europe closer to the very military engagement they profess to fear.
## Historical Parallels and the Way Forward
Fazi’s analysis invites comparis
Transcript
Journalist Exposes EU "Hybrid War" Lies |
Thomas Fazi
They are lying to you about the Russia's supposed "Hybrid War". The question is why are they lying?
To transform the entire EU into the next mega Ukraine? To back save their own power? To create
mass-hysteria? Or all of the above? Thomas Fazi joins Pascal to debunk claims of Russian hybrid
warfare in Europe. Drawing on his recent investigation, Fazi questions the evidence behind
prominent sabotage allegations, drone scares and media coverage. They discuss the Leipzig airport
case, political incentives, defence industry interests and the distinction between propaganda and
collective fear. The conversation also explores censorship, civil liberties and historical parallels, while
warning that escalating threat narratives could contribute to a real confrontation between NATO and
Russia, with dangerous consequences. Thomas's Links: Substack: https://www.thomasfazi.com/ The
Russian hybrid war narrative — full article: https://www.thomasfazi.com/p/the-russian-hybrid-war-
narrative Responsible Statecraft — shorter article: https://responsiblestatecraft.org/hybrid-warfare-
russia/ X: https://twitter.com/battleforeurope Die Brüsseler Tyrannei — German book:
https://westendverlag.de/Die-Bruesseler-Tyrannei/2495 Neutrality Studies Links: Neutrality Studies
Substack: https://pascallottaz.substack.com Support Neutrality Studies: https://neutralitystudies.com
/donate Neutrality Studies shop: https://neutralitystudies.com/shop Time Stamps 00:00 Examining
the Russian hybrid war narrative 06:18 From allegations to specific incidents 11:18 Drone scares and
the evidence 20:51 Leipzig airport and demands for proof 31:28 Media incentives and threat inflation
37:26 Cognitive warfare and collective fear 45:07 Rearmament and defence industry interests 50:21
Civil liberties and the risk of escalation
#Pascal
Welcome back, everybody, to Neutrality Studies. Today we have an update with our brilliant Italian
colleague, author, writer, and journalist Thomas Fazi, who recently wrote a beautiful piece on his
Substack called “Russian Hybrid War Narrative: A New NATO Strategy of Tension.” Thomas,
welcome.
#Thomas Fazi
Hi, Pascal. Thanks a lot for having me. It's always a pleasure.
#Pascal
Thank you for coming back, and thank you for writing this. I've wanted to do an episode on this
whole hybrid warfare narrative of the NATO crowd for a while. And then you wrote basically
everything into your article. Can we start taking this apart? Where do you think we need to begin in
-- 1 of 15 --
order to wrap our minds around what hybrid war now actually means to the Europeans and the
transatlanticists?
#Thomas Fazi
Right. Well, I mean, the reason I wrote this article was precisely because I realized that there was
no comprehensive critical analysis or debunking of this Russian hybrid war narrative that we've been
hearing now for several years, basically since Russia's invasion of Ukraine. And of course, many
individual incidents and claims have been debunked. In fact, as we'll see over the course of our talk,
virtually every claim of Russian hybrid warfare has been debunked in one way or another. But the
problem is that you can debunk an individual case, but by the time you've debunked that one claim,
they've already thrown another ten claims at you.
And of course, you know, it ebbs and flows, this narrative, right? So these days, we don't hear that
much about it. But a couple of months ago, and in fact even more recently, almost not a day went
by without some claim of Russian hybrid warfare being spun in the media, be it a drone scare, a fire,
a blackout, you know, a defense factory in Europe catching fire, a drone hybrid attack. Of course,
cyberattacks. Everything that goes wrong, you know, every time a computer fails in Europe, it's a
Russian cyberattack, right? And so it ebbs and flows, but when they start ramping up the narrative,
it's almost impossible to catch up, right?
And so at some point, I realized that, okay, we need a comprehensive debunking, not just of those
individual cases. I wanted to look at almost every individual claim and see how much truth, if any,
there was to all these claims, right? So essentially, I wanted to compile a database of these claims
and their debunkings. And I felt this was really necessary because I think the way that propaganda
operates these days—and I think this is pretty clear when it comes to these claims of Russian hybrid
warfare—is not that they make up one big, elaborate lie, right? They make up thousands of tiny lies,
which aren't even that elaborate, right?
And in fact, in most cases, they're very easily shown to be false, or there's no evidence of Russia
being behind them. But that doesn't really matter because whenever these claims are eventually
proven to be untrue, the retraction gets a fraction of the coverage of the initial claim. So that doesn't
really matter. You know, you just need to keep putting out claims on a daily basis, and it creates this
kind of background noise, you know, “Russian hybrid warfare, Russian hybrid warfare” in the
background, you know, and most people won't even get to read or see the retractions.
So what will get stuck in their heads is the initial claim about Russia. And of course, they preface
many of these claims with “allegedly.” Russia is allegedly behind this incident, is allegedly behind this
sabotage, is allegedly behind this fire. But of course, what remains stuck in the public's head is, you
know, okay, Russia allegedly did a million things. But if they're allegedly carrying out a million
-- 2 of 15 --
different acts of sabotage across Europe, then that must be serious, right? So I wanted to compile a
kind of counter-database because, of course, we have several databases of these supposed acts of
Russian sabotage.
So I guess my article is a kind of counter-database, an antidote to the noise, because it's important
to realize that the noise is the propaganda these days, right? It's this background noise that is
almost sort of, you know, permanently present. And so hopefully, thanks to my article, whenever
people hear the latest claim of Russian sabotage, they can go to the article and see how this fits a
pattern that we've seen throughout the past few years. And hopefully this will help them sort of, you
know, drown out the noise, right?
Because I think that's really what needs to be done, and no one had done it. And that's why the
original article, which I published on my Substack, is like 15 pages long, because I really felt the
need to go through almost every one of these claims. And then I published a shorter version on
Responsible Statecraft, which is the Quincy Institute's publication. So viewers, if they want the short
version, they can read the one on Responsible Statecraft. But if they want the deep dive, they can
find that on my Substack.
#Pascal
Okay, and now let's unpack this a little bit—the hybrid war and the instances that you chronicled.
And after that, I'll ask you more about the context, right? Because this is not the first time that we're
seeing the NATO crowd using this type of very elusive terminology in order to scare people. But we'll
do that in the second part. What is the first instance that you started with, where you said, like,
okay, this is where they discovered “hybrid warfare” as a term and as something to put out there?
#Thomas Fazi
Right. Well, I mean, virtually since the moment Russia invaded, we've been seeing this escalating
narrative.
#Pascal
In 2022, basically.
#Thomas Fazi
This is really when the narrative starts to seriously ramp up. But it really kind of picks up around
2024, 2025. I think in 2024, it really kind of explodes. And we start hearing sort of two versions of
this hybrid warfare. So we're told, for one, that Russia is engaging in various forms of physical
interference within Europe, within NATO territory. And we start hearing about several incidents that
are then blamed on Russia. Hey, just a very quick note.
-- 3 of 15 --
#Pascal
The best way to support this channel is by signing up for my free Substack. You can also help with a
paid subscription there, or you can get some of our new merch on neutralitystudies.com. Links
below. See you there.
#Thomas Fazi
So, for example, in 2024, widespread coverage was given to these undersea cables that had been
damaged in the Baltic Sea. And almost immediately, there was speculation that Russia was behind it.
The media and the political establishment, in many cases, openly attributed these incidents to
Russia. In fact, an investigation later revealed that those cables had most likely been damaged by
accident by Chinese- and Hong Kong-flagged ships. So no Russian vessel was involved. The Russians
were not involved in damaging these cables. But of course, again, how many people know that the
initial claim has been debunked?
#Thomas Fazi
And then we start hearing more and more about these incidents. I think it was also in late 2024 that
a DHL plane crashed in Lithuania. This was a cargo plane. And many politicians sort of implied or
openly said that this was a hybrid incident. I think, you know, Annalena Baerbock, Germany's
ambassador and former foreign minister, openly said that this was a hybrid incident and that most
likely Russia was behind it. And other politicians made similar claims. In fact, it was later revealed in
an investigation that the crash was due to pilot error and had nothing to do with any state's
interference, let alone Russia's. There was quite a widely publicized incident in the UK. This was in
early 2025, when Heathrow Airport was closed down due to an electrical substation catching fire.
And even back then, in the British media, many intelligence experts went on to claim that this was
something straight out of Russia's military intelligence playbook and that most likely Russia was
behind it. In fact, it was then revealed that this was simply a case of a private company not properly
maintaining the installation, which is why the fire broke out. And you see a similar pattern in so
many of these cases. But I think it really kind of explodes in the autumn of 2025, when we have the
Russian drone hysteria, right? That's when I initially started assembling notes for this article, which I
then had to put aside because life kind of took over.
I mean, I'm sure viewers will remember that in late 2025, for several months, hardly a day went by
without reported sightings of suspicious drones, usually near airports or military installations. This
was very intense in Scandinavia, especially Denmark and Norway, with several cases in the Baltic
countries. Several airports temporarily shut down because of this drone panic, including in Germany.
Frankfurt Airport was shut down for a while. And there were wild claims. European politicians openly
-- 4 of 15 --
claimed that these were Russian drones and that this was part of Russia's escalating hybrid warfare
against Europe. Merz in Germany openly said, “We suspect Russia is behind most of these drone
flights.” And then there were even wilder claims.
I think a Danish politician compared the situation to 9/11. There were incredibly wild claims. But it
was really something. I mean, I remember that's when I decided, no, I really have to take a deep
look at all these claims. But, you know, as I said earlier, I was struggling to catch up. So I started
looking into one sighting, and then the next day there were another four sightings. So at some point
it was like, okay, I need to put this aside. I haven't got enough time to really look at every single
case. But luckily, others did that at the time. There was one very good investigation by a Dutch
newspaper, Trouw. I don't know if I'm pronouncing that right. But anyway, they looked at around 60
drone incidents around that time. And what they found was that there was a lot of panic and hardly
any evidence of Russian involvement.
Essentially, what they found was that virtually every o